Security Group vs NACL

Ever wonder how AWS protects a network at different levels, from individual servers to entire network segments? The answer lies in two key tools: Security groups and Network Access Control List (NACL). Security Groups are stateful firewalls that protect a single virtual server, while NACLs act as a stateless firewall for an entire subnet. Together, they create a powerful and layered security model, protecting thousands of instances and subnets within a single VPC.

What are Security Groups?

A Security Group in AWS acts as a virtual firewall for your individual resources. It controls inbound and outbound network traffic to and from things like EC2 instances. Being “stateful,” it automatically allows return traffic for permitted connections. You configure it with “allow” rules, specifying protocols and ports, and can associate multiple Security Groups with a single resource for flexible security.

Key Features of Security Group

1. Instance-Level Control: Security Groups operate directly at the instance or network interface level. This means you define rules for specific resources, giving you granular control over the traffic that reaches or leaves them.

2. Stateful Operation: Security Groups are “stateful.” This is a critical convenience feature. Suppose you allow an inbound connection (e.g., someone connecting to your web server on port 80). In that case, the Security Group automatically permits the outbound return traffic for that same connection, even if you don’t have an explicit outbound rule for it. This simplifies rule management.

3. Allow-Only Rules: Security Groups exclusively support “allow” rules. You cannot explicitly define “deny” rules. If traffic doesn’t match an “allow” rule, it is implicitly denied. This design philosophy emphasizes a whitelist approach to security.

4. Multiple Security Groups per Resource: You can associate an AWS resource with multiple Security Groups. The rules from all associated Security Groups are effectively combined (logically OR’d) to determine whether traffic is allowed. This provides flexibility in creating different security policies for various aspects of an application.

5. Dynamic Updates: Changes to Security Group rules are applied almost immediately to all associated instances. This allows for quick adjustments to your security posture without requiring downtime or reboots of your resources.

What is NACL?

A Network Access Control List (NACL) in AWS functions as a stateless firewall for entire subnets within a VPC. It controls both inbound and outbound traffic based on numbered rules evaluated in order. NACLs explicitly support both allow and deny rules, providing fine-grained control at the subnet level. Unlike Security Groups, you must define rules for both directions of traffic flow. They offer a crucial, optional layer of network security to supplement instance-level controls.

Key Features of NACL

1. Subnet-Level Control: NACLs are associated directly with subnets within your VPC. All traffic entering or leaving any instance within that subnet must pass through and be evaluated by the associated NACL.

2. Stateless Operation: Unlike Security Groups, NACLs are “stateless.” This means they do not remember previous connection states. If you allow inbound traffic on a specific port, you must explicitly create a separate outbound rule to permit the return traffic for that connection.

3. Numbered Rules and Order of Evaluation: Each rule in a NACL is assigned a unique number (from 1 to 32766). NACLs evaluate rules in numerical order, from the lowest to the highest number. As soon as a rule matches the traffic, the action (allow or deny) is applied, and no further rules are evaluated for that specific packet. This makes the rule order crucial.

4. Allow and Deny Rules: NACLs support both “allow” and “deny” rules. This provides a powerful ability to explicitly block specific IP addresses, ports, or protocols at the subnet boundary, offering more precise control than Security Groups, which only support “allow” rules.

5. Default NACL Behavior: When you create a new VPC, a default NACL is automatically created and associated with all subnets. This default NACL allows all inbound and outbound traffic. However, when you make a custom NACL, its default behavior is to deny all inbound and outbound traffic, requiring you to define all permitted traffic explicitly.

Security Group vs NACL

Features	Security Groups (SGs)	Network Access Control Lists (NACLs)
Scope	Instance level	Subnet level
Statefulness	Stateful (outbound response automatically allowed)	Stateless (both inbound and outbound must be explicitly allowed)
Order of Defense	Second layer (after NACLs)	First layer (at subnet boundary)
Primary Use	Protecting individual instances/applications	Subnet-level traffic filtering
Default	Denies inbound, allows outbound (for new SGs)	Allows all traffic (for default NACLs), Denies all (for custom)

Advanced Cloud Security Governance Training with InfosecTrain

Security Groups and NACLs are distinct yet vital for AWS network security, with SGs managing instance-level traffic and NACLs handling broader subnet filtering. Understanding their unique roles is key to building a robust cloud architecture. To further master such distinctions and comprehensive cloud security governance, including preparing for CCAK and CCSK exams, InfosecTrain’s advanced courses offer in-depth learning. These programs ensure you gain the expertise needed to design and implement highly secure cloud environments with confidence.